Thanks to @soloestoy for discovering this issue in #5667.
This is an alternative fix in order to avoid both cycling the clients
and also disconnecting clients just having valid read-only transactions
pending.
In Redis 4.0 replication, with the introduction of PSYNC2, masters and
slaves replicate commands to cascading slaves and to the replication
backlog itself in a different way compared to the past.
Masters actually replicate the effects of client commands.
Slaves just propagate what they receive from masters.
This mechanism can cause problems when the configuration of an instance
is changed from master to slave inside a transaction. For instance
we could send to a master instance the following sequence:
MULTI
SLAVEOF 127.0.0.1 0
EXEC
SLAVEOF NO ONE
Before the fixes in this commit, the MULTI command used to be propagated
into the replication backlog, however after the SLAVEOF command the
instance is a slave, so the EXEC implementation failed to also propagate
the EXEC command. When the slaves of the above instance reconnected,
they were incrementally synchronized just sending a "MULTI". This put
the master client (in the slaves) into MULTI state, breaking the
replication.
Notably even Redis Sentinel uses the above approach in order to guarantee
that configuration changes are always performed together with rewrites
of the configuration and with clients disconnection. Sentiel does:
MULTI
SLAVEOF ...
CONFIG REWRITE
CLIENT KILL TYPE normal
EXEC
So this was a really problematic issue. However even with the fix in
this commit, that will add the final EXEC to the replication stream in
case the instance was switched from master to slave during the
transaction, the result would be to increment the slave replication
offset, so a successive reconnection with the new master, will not
permit a successful partial resynchronization: no way the new master can
provide us with the backlog needed, we incremented our offset to a value
that the new master cannot have.
However the EXEC implementation waits to emit the MULTI, so that if the
commands inside the transaction actually do not need to be replicated,
no commands propagation happens at all. From multi.c:
if (!must_propagate && !(c->cmd->flags & (CMD_READONLY|CMD_ADMIN))) {
execCommandPropagateMulti(c);
must_propagate = 1;
}
The above code is already modified by this commit you are reading.
Now also ADMIN commands do not trigger the emission of MULTI. It is actually
not clear why we do not just check for CMD_WRITE... Probably I wrote it this
way in order to make the code more reliable: better to over-emit MULTI
than not emitting it in time.
So this commit should indeed fix issue #3836 (verified), however it looks
like some reconsideration of this code path is needed in the long term.
BONUS POINT: The reverse bug.
Even in a read only slave "B", in a replication setup like:
A -> B -> C
There are commands without the READONLY nor the ADMIN flag, that are also
not flagged as WRITE commands. An example is just the PING command.
So if we send B the following sequence:
MULTI
PING
SLAVEOF NO ONE
EXEC
The result will be the reverse bug, where only EXEC is emitted, but not the
previous MULTI. However this apparently does not create problems in practice
but it is yet another acknowledge of the fact some work is needed here
in order to make this code path less surprising.
Note that there are many different approaches we could follow. For instance
MULTI/EXEC blocks containing administrative commands may be allowed ONLY
if all the commands are administrative ones, otherwise they could be
denined. When allowed, the commands could simply never be replicated at all.
MULTI/EXEC is now propagated to the AOF / Slaves only once we encounter
the first command that is not a read-only one inside the transaction.
The old behavior was to always propagate an empty MULTI/EXEC block when
the transaction was composed just of read only commands, or even
completely empty. This created two problems:
1) It's a bandwidth waste in the replication link and a space waste
inside the AOF file.
2) We used to always increment server.dirty to force the propagation of
the EXEC command, resulting into triggering RDB saves more often
than needed.
Note: even read-only commands may also trigger writes that will be
propagated, when we access a key that is found expired and Redis will
synthesize a DEL operation. However there is no need for this to stay
inside the transaction itself, but only to be ordered.
So for instance something like:
MULTI
GET foo
SET key zap
EXEC
May be propagated into:
DEL foo
MULTI
SET key zap
EXEC
While the DEL is outside the transaction, the commands are delivered in
the right order and it is not possible for other commands to be inserted
between DEL and MULTI.
After the transcation starts with a MULIT, the previous behavior was to
return an error on problems such as maxmemory limit reached. But still
to execute the transaction with the subset of queued commands on EXEC.
While it is true that the client was able to check for errors
distinguish QUEUED by an error reply, MULTI/EXEC in most client
implementations uses pipelining for speed, so all the commands and EXEC
are sent without caring about replies.
With this change:
1) EXEC fails if at least one command was not queued because of an
error. The EXECABORT error is used.
2) A generic error is always reported on EXEC.
3) The client DISCARDs the MULTI state after a failed EXEC, otherwise
pipelining multiple transactions would be basically impossible:
After a failed EXEC the next transaction would be simply queued as
the tail of the previous transaction.
Before of this commit it used to be like this:
MULTI
EXEC
... actual commands of the transaction ...
Because after all that is the natural order of things. Transaction
commands are queued and executed *only after* EXEC is called.
However this makes debugging with MONITOR a mess, so the code was
modified to provide a coherent output.
What happens is that MULTI is rendered in the MONITOR output as far as
possible, instead EXEC is propagated only after the transaction is
executed, or even in the case it fails because of WATCH, so in this case
you'll simply see:
MULTI
EXEC
An empty transaction.
This commit introduces support for read only slaves via redis.conf and CONFIG GET/SET commands. Also various semantical fixes are implemented here:
1) MULTI/EXEC with only read commands now work where the server is into a state where writes (or commands increasing memory usage) are not allowed. Before this patch everything inside a transaction would fail in this conditions.
2) Scripts just calling read-only commands will work against read only
slaves, when the server is out of memory, or when persistence is into an
error condition. Before the patch EVAL always failed in this condition.
networking related stuff moved into networking.c
moved more code
more work on layout of source code
SDS instantaneuos memory saving. By Pieter and Salvatore at VMware ;)
cleanly compiling again after the first split, now splitting it in more C files
moving more things around... work in progress
split replication code
splitting more
Sets split
Hash split
replication split
even more splitting
more splitting
minor change
