Motivation: for applications that use RM ACL verification functions, they would
want to return errors back to the user, in ways that are consistent with Redis.
While investigating how we should return ACL errors to the user, we realized that
Redis isn't consistent, and currently returns ACL error strings in 3 primary ways.
[For the actual implications of this change, see the "Impact" section at the bottom]
1. how it returns an error when calling a command normally
ACL_DENIED_CMD -> "this user has no permissions to run the '%s' command"
ACL_DENIED_KEY -> "this user has no permissions to access one of the keys used as arguments"
ACL_DENIED_CHANNEL -> "this user has no permissions to access one of the channels used as arguments"
2. how it returns an error when calling via 'acl dryrun' command
ACL_DENIED_CMD -> "This user has no permissions to run the '%s' command"
ACL_DENIED_KEY -> "This user has no permissions to access the '%s' key"
ACL_DENIED_CHANNEL -> "This user has no permissions to access the '%s' channel"
3. how it returns an error via RM_Call (and scripting is similar).
ACL_DENIED_CMD -> "can't run this command or subcommand";
ACL_DENIED_KEY -> "can't access at least one of the keys mentioned in the command arguments";
ACL_DENIED_CHANNEL -> "can't publish to the channel mentioned in the command";
In addition, if one wants to use RM_Call's "dry run" capability instead of the RM ACL
functions directly, one also sees a different problem than it returns ACL errors with a -ERR,
not a -PERM, so it can't be returned directly to the caller.
This PR modifies the code to generate a base message in a common manner with the ability
to set verbose flag for acl dry run errors, and keep it unset for normal/rm_call/script cases
```c
sds getAclErrorMessage(int acl_res, user *user, struct redisCommand *cmd, sds errored_val, int verbose) {
switch (acl_res) {
case ACL_DENIED_CMD:
return sdscatfmt(sdsempty(), "User %S has no permissions to run "
"the '%S' command", user->name, cmd->fullname);
case ACL_DENIED_KEY:
if (verbose) {
return sdscatfmt(sdsempty(), "User %S has no permissions to access "
"the '%S' key", user->name, errored_val);
} else {
return sdsnew("No permissions to access a key");
}
case ACL_DENIED_CHANNEL:
if (verbose) {
return sdscatfmt(sdsempty(), "User %S has no permissions to access "
"the '%S' channel", user->name, errored_val);
} else {
return sdsnew("No permissions to access a channel");
}
}
```
The caller can append/prepend the message (adding NOPERM for normal/RM_Call or indicating it's within a script).
Impact:
- Plain commands, as well as scripts and RM_Call now include the user name.
- ACL DRYRUN remains the only one that's verbose (mentions the offending channel or key name)
- Changes RM_Call ACL errors from being a `-ERR` to being `-NOPERM` (besides for textual changes)
**This somewhat a breaking change, but it only affects the RM_Call with both `C` and `E`, or `D`**
- Changes ACL errors in scripts textually from being
`The user executing the script <old non unified text>`
to
`ACL failure in script: <new unified text>`
The original idea behind auto-setting the default (first,last,step) spec was to use
the most "open" flags when the user didn't provide any key-spec flags information.
While the above idea is a good approach, it really makes no sense to set
CMD_KEY_VARIABLE_FLAGS if the user didn't provide the getkeys-api flag:
in this case there's not way to retrieve these variable flags, so what's the point?
Internally in redis there was code to ignore this already, so this fix doesn't change
redis's behavior, it only affects the output of COMMAND command.
The SET and BITFIELD command were added `get_keys_function` in #10148, causing
them to be wrongly marked movablekeys in `populateCommandMovableKeys`.
This was an unintended side effect introduced in #10148 (7.0 RC1)
which could cause some clients an extra round trip for these commands in cluster mode.
Since we define movablekeys as a way to determine if the legacy range [first, last, step]
doesn't find all keys, then we need a completely different approach.
The right approach should be to check if the legacy range covers all key-specs,
and if none of the key-specs have the INCOMPLETE flag.
This way, we don't need to look at getkeys_proc of VARIABLE_FLAG at all.
Probably with the exception of modules, who may still not be using key-specs.
In this PR, we removed `populateCommandMovableKeys` and put its logic in
`populateCommandLegacyRangeSpec`.
In order to properly serve both old and new modules, we must probably keep relying
CMD_MODULE_GETKEYS, but do that only for modules that don't declare key-specs.
For ones that do, we need to take the same approach we take with native redis commands.
This approach was proposed by Oran. Fixes#10833
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
- add COMMAND GETKEYSANDFLAGS sub-command
- add RM_KeyAtPosWithFlags and GetCommandKeysWithFlags
- RM_KeyAtPos and RM_CreateCommand set flags requiring full access for keys
- RM_CreateCommand set VARIABLE_FLAGS
- expose `variable_flags` flag in COMMAND INFO key-specs
- getKeysFromCommandWithSpecs prefers key-specs over getkeys-api
- add tests for all of these
Adds RM_SetCommandInfo, allowing modules to provide the following command info:
* summary
* complexity
* since
* history
* hints
* arity
* key specs
* args
This information affects the output of `COMMAND`, `COMMAND INFO` and `COMMAND DOCS`,
Cluster, ACL and is used to filter commands with the wrong number of arguments before
the call reaches the module code.
The recently added API functions for key specs (never released) are removed.
A minimalist example would look like so:
```c
RedisModuleCommand *mycmd = RedisModule_GetCommand(ctx,"mymodule.mycommand");
RedisModuleCommandInfo mycmd_info = {
.version = REDISMODULE_COMMAND_INFO_VERSION,
.arity = -5,
.summary = "some description",
};
if (RedisModule_SetCommandInfo(mycmd, &mycmd_info) == REDISMODULE_ERR)
return REDISMODULE_ERR;
````
Notes:
* All the provided information (including strings) is copied, not keeping references to the API input data.
* The version field is actually a static struct that contains the sizes of the the structs used in arrays,
so we can extend these in the future and old version will still be able to take the part they can support.
The keyspec API is not yet released and there is a plan to change it
in #10108, which is going to be included in RC2. Therefore, we hide
it in RC1 to avoid introducing a breaking change in RC2.
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
Summary of changes:
1. Rename `redisCommand->name` to `redisCommand->declared_name`, it is a
const char * for native commands and SDS for module commands.
2. Store the [sub]command fullname in `redisCommand->fullname` (sds).
3. List subcommands in `ACL CAT`
4. List subcommands in `COMMAND LIST`
5. `moduleUnregisterCommands` now will also free the module subcommands.
6. RM_GetCurrentCommandName returns full command name
Other changes:
1. Add `addReplyErrorArity` and `addReplyErrorExpireTime`
2. Remove `getFullCommandName` function that now is useless.
3. Some cleanups about `fullname` since now it is SDS.
4. Delete `populateSingleCommand` function from server.h that is useless.
5. Added tests to cover this change.
6. Add some module unload tests and fix the leaks
7. Make error messages uniform, make sure they always contain the full command
name and that it's quoted.
7. Fixes some typos
see the history in #9504, fixes#10124
Co-authored-by: Oran Agra <oran@redislabs.com>
Co-authored-by: guybe7 <guy.benoish@redislabs.com>
The new ACL key based permissions in #9974 require the key-specs (#8324) to have more
explicit flags rather than just READ and WRITE. See discussion in #10040
This PR defines two groups of flags:
One about how redis internally handles the key (mutually-exclusive).
The other is about the logical operation done from the user's point of view (3 mutually exclusive
write flags, and one read flag, all optional).
In both groups, if we can't explicitly flag something as explicit read-only, delete-only, or
insert-only, we flag it as `RW` or `UPDATE`.
here's the definition from the code:
```
/* Key-spec flags *
* -------------- */
/* The following refer what the command actually does with the value or metadata
* of the key, and not necessarily the user data or how it affects it.
* Each key-spec may must have exaclty one of these. Any operation that's not
* distinctly deletion, overwrite or read-only would be marked as RW. */
#define CMD_KEY_RO (1ULL<<0) /* Read-Only - Reads the value of the key, but
* doesn't necessarily returns it. */
#define CMD_KEY_RW (1ULL<<1) /* Read-Write - Modifies the data stored in the
* value of the key or its metadata. */
#define CMD_KEY_OW (1ULL<<2) /* Overwrite - Overwrites the data stored in
* the value of the key. */
#define CMD_KEY_RM (1ULL<<3) /* Deletes the key. */
/* The follwing refer to user data inside the value of the key, not the metadata
* like LRU, type, cardinality. It refers to the logical operation on the user's
* data (actual input strings / TTL), being used / returned / copied / changed,
* It doesn't refer to modification or returning of metadata (like type, count,
* presence of data). Any write that's not INSERT or DELETE, would be an UPADTE.
* Each key-spec may have one of the writes with or without access, or none: */
#define CMD_KEY_ACCESS (1ULL<<4) /* Returns, copies or uses the user data from
* the value of the key. */
#define CMD_KEY_UPDATE (1ULL<<5) /* Updates data to the value, new value may
* depend on the old value. */
#define CMD_KEY_INSERT (1ULL<<6) /* Adds data to the value with no chance of,
* modification or deletion of existing data. */
#define CMD_KEY_DELETE (1ULL<<7) /* Explicitly deletes some content
* from the value of the key. */
```
Unrelated changes:
- generate-command-code.py is only compatible with python3 (modified the shabang)
- generate-command-code.py print file on json parsing error
- rename `shard_channel` key-spec flag to just `channel`.
- add INCOMPLETE flag in input spec of SORT and SORT_RO
Syntax:
`COMMAND DOCS [<command name> ...]`
Background:
Apparently old version of hiredis (and thus also redis-cli) can't
support more than 7 levels of multi-bulk nesting.
The solution is to move all the doc related metadata from COMMAND to a
new COMMAND DOCS sub-command.
The new DOCS sub-command returns a map of commands (not an array like in COMMAND),
And the same goes for the `subcommands` field inside it (also contains a map)
Besides that, the remaining new fields of COMMAND (hints, key-specs, and
sub-commands), are placed in the outer array rather than a nested map.
this was done mainly for consistency with the old format.
Other changes:
---
* Allow COMMAND INFO with no arguments, which returns all commands, so that we can some day deprecated
the plain COMMAND (no args)
* Reduce the amount of deferred replies from both COMMAND and COMMAND
DOCS, especially in the inner loops, since these create many small
reply objects, which lead to many small write syscalls and many small
TCP packets.
To make this easier, when populating the command table, we count the
history, args, and hints so we later know their size in advance.
Additionally, the movablekeys flag was moved into the flags register.
* Update generate-commands-json.py to take the data from both command, it
now executes redis-cli directly, instead of taking input from stdin.
* Sub-commands in both COMMAND (and COMMAND INFO), and also COMMAND DOCS,
show their full name. i.e. CONFIG
* GET will be shown as `config|get` rather than just `get`.
This will be visible both when asking for `COMMAND INFO config` and COMMAND INFO config|get`, but is
especially important for the later.
i.e. imagine someone doing `COMMAND INFO slowlog|get config|get` not being able to distinguish between the two
items in the array response.
Following #9656, this script generates a "commands.json" file from the output
of the new COMMAND. The output of this script is used in redis/redis-doc#1714
and by redis/redis-io#259. This also converts a couple of rogue dashes (in
'key-specs' and 'multiple-token' flags) to underscores (continues #9959).
some languages can build a json-like object by parsing a textual json,
but it works poorly when attributes contain hyphens
example in JS:
```
let j = JSON.parse(json)
j['key-name'] <- works
j.key-name <= illegal syntax
```
Delete the hardcoded command table and replace it with an auto-generated table, based
on a JSON file that describes the commands (each command must have a JSON file).
These JSON files are the SSOT of everything there is to know about Redis commands,
and it is reflected fully in COMMAND INFO.
These JSON files are used to generate commands.c (using a python script), which is then
committed to the repo and compiled.
The purpose is:
* Clients and proxies will be able to get much more info from redis, instead of relying on hard coded logic.
* drop the dependency between Redis-user and the commands.json in redis-doc.
* delete help.h and have redis-cli learn everything it needs to know just by issuing COMMAND (will be
done in a separate PR)
* redis.io should stop using commands.json and learn everything from Redis (ultimately one of the release
artifacts should be a large JSON, containing all the information about all of the commands, which will be
generated from COMMAND's reply)
* the byproduct of this is:
* module commands will be able to provide that info and possibly be more of a first-class citizens
* in theory, one may be able to generate a redis client library for a strictly typed language, by using this info.
### Interface changes
#### COMMAND INFO's reply change (and arg-less COMMAND)
Before this commit the reply at index 7 contained the key-specs list
and reply at index 8 contained the sub-commands list (Both unreleased).
Now, reply at index 7 is a map of:
- summary - short command description
- since - debut version
- group - command group
- complexity - complexity string
- doc-flags - flags used for documentation (e.g. "deprecated")
- deprecated-since - if deprecated, from which version?
- replaced-by - if deprecated, which command replaced it?
- history - a list of (version, what-changed) tuples
- hints - a list of strings, meant to provide hints for clients/proxies. see https://github.com/redis/redis/issues/9876
- arguments - an array of arguments. each element is a map, with the possibility of nesting (sub-arguments)
- key-specs - an array of keys specs (already in unstable, just changed location)
- subcommands - a list of sub-commands (already in unstable, just changed location)
- reply-schema - will be added in the future (see https://github.com/redis/redis/issues/9845)
more details on these can be found in https://github.com/redis/redis-doc/pull/1697
only the first three fields are mandatory
#### API changes (unreleased API obviously)
now they take RedisModuleCommand opaque pointer instead of looking up the command by name
- RM_CreateSubcommand
- RM_AddCommandKeySpec
- RM_SetCommandKeySpecBeginSearchIndex
- RM_SetCommandKeySpecBeginSearchKeyword
- RM_SetCommandKeySpecFindKeysRange
- RM_SetCommandKeySpecFindKeysKeynum
Currently, we did not add module API to provide additional information about their commands because
we couldn't agree on how the API should look like, see https://github.com/redis/redis/issues/9944.
### Somehow related changes
1. Literals should be in uppercase while placeholder in lowercase. Now all the GEO* command
will be documented with M|KM|FT|MI and can take both lowercase and uppercase
### Unrelated changes
1. Bugfix: no_madaory_keys was absent in COMMAND's reply
2. expose CMD_MODULE as "module" via COMMAND
3. have a dedicated uint64 for ACL categories (instead of having them in the same uint64 as command flags)
Co-authored-by: Itamar Haber <itamar@garantiadata.com>
## Intro
The purpose is to allow having different flags/ACL categories for
subcommands (Example: CONFIG GET is ok-loading but CONFIG SET isn't)
We create a small command table for every command that has subcommands
and each subcommand has its own flags, etc. (same as a "regular" command)
This commit also unites the Redis and the Sentinel command tables
## Affected commands
CONFIG
Used to have "admin ok-loading ok-stale no-script"
Changes:
1. Dropped "ok-loading" in all except GET (this doesn't change behavior since
there were checks in the code doing that)
XINFO
Used to have "read-only random"
Changes:
1. Dropped "random" in all except CONSUMERS
XGROUP
Used to have "write use-memory"
Changes:
1. Dropped "use-memory" in all except CREATE and CREATECONSUMER
COMMAND
No changes.
MEMORY
Used to have "random read-only"
Changes:
1. Dropped "random" in PURGE and USAGE
ACL
Used to have "admin no-script ok-loading ok-stale"
Changes:
1. Dropped "admin" in WHOAMI, GENPASS, and CAT
LATENCY
No changes.
MODULE
No changes.
SLOWLOG
Used to have "admin random ok-loading ok-stale"
Changes:
1. Dropped "random" in RESET
OBJECT
Used to have "read-only random"
Changes:
1. Dropped "random" in ENCODING and REFCOUNT
SCRIPT
Used to have "may-replicate no-script"
Changes:
1. Dropped "may-replicate" in all except FLUSH and LOAD
CLIENT
Used to have "admin no-script random ok-loading ok-stale"
Changes:
1. Dropped "random" in all except INFO and LIST
2. Dropped "admin" in ID, TRACKING, CACHING, GETREDIR, INFO, SETNAME, GETNAME, and REPLY
STRALGO
No changes.
PUBSUB
No changes.
CLUSTER
Changes:
1. Dropped "admin in countkeysinslots, getkeysinslot, info, nodes, keyslot, myid, and slots
SENTINEL
No changes.
(note that DEBUG also fits, but we decided not to convert it since it's for
debugging and anyway undocumented)
## New sub-command
This commit adds another element to the per-command output of COMMAND,
describing the list of subcommands, if any (in the same structure as "regular" commands)
Also, it adds a new subcommand:
```
COMMAND LIST [FILTERBY (MODULE <module-name>|ACLCAT <cat>|PATTERN <pattern>)]
```
which returns a set of all commands (unless filters), but excluding subcommands.
## Module API
A new module API, RM_CreateSubcommand, was added, in order to allow
module writer to define subcommands
## ACL changes:
1. Now, that each subcommand is actually a command, each has its own ACL id.
2. The old mechanism of allowed_subcommands is redundant
(blocking/allowing a subcommand is the same as blocking/allowing a regular command),
but we had to keep it, to support the widespread usage of allowed_subcommands
to block commands with certain args, that aren't subcommands (e.g. "-select +select|0").
3. I have renamed allowed_subcommands to allowed_firstargs to emphasize the difference.
4. Because subcommands are commands in ACL too, you can now use "-" to block subcommands
(e.g. "+client -client|kill"), which wasn't possible in the past.
5. It is also possible to use the allowed_firstargs mechanism with subcommand.
For example: `+config -config|set +config|set|loglevel` will block all CONFIG SET except
for setting the log level.
6. All of the ACL changes above required some amount of refactoring.
## Misc
1. There are two approaches: Either each subcommand has its own function or all
subcommands use the same function, determining what to do according to argv[0].
For now, I took the former approaches only with CONFIG and COMMAND,
while other commands use the latter approach (for smaller blamelog diff).
2. Deleted memoryGetKeys: It is no longer needed because MEMORY USAGE now uses the "range" key spec.
4. Bugfix: GETNAME was missing from CLIENT's help message.
5. Sentinel and Redis now use the same table, with the same function pointer.
Some commands have a different implementation in Sentinel, so we redirect
them (these are ROLE, PUBLISH, and INFO).
6. Command stats now show the stats per subcommand (e.g. instead of stats just
for "config" you will have stats for "config|set", "config|get", etc.)
7. It is now possible to use COMMAND directly on subcommands:
COMMAND INFO CONFIG|GET (The pipeline syntax was inspired from ACL, and
can be used in functions lookupCommandBySds and lookupCommandByCString)
8. STRALGO is now a container command (has "help")
## Breaking changes:
1. Command stats now show the stats per subcommand (see (5) above)
Fix#7297
The problem:
Today, there is no way for a client library or app to know the key name indexes for commands such as
ZUNIONSTORE/EVAL and others with "numkeys", since COMMAND INFO returns no useful info for them.
For cluster-aware redis clients, this requires to 'patch' the client library code specifically for each of these commands or to
resolve each execution of these commands with COMMAND GETKEYS.
The solution:
Introducing key specs other than the legacy "range" (first,last,step)
The 8th element of the command info array, if exists, holds an array of key specs. The array may be empty, which indicates
the command doesn't take any key arguments or may contain one or more key-specs, each one may leads to the discovery
of 0 or more key arguments.
A client library that doesn't support this key-spec feature will keep using the first,last,step and movablekeys flag which will
obviously remain unchanged.
A client that supports this key-specs feature needs only to look at the key-specs array. If it finds an unrecognized spec, it
must resort to using COMMAND GETKEYS if it wishes to get all key name arguments, but if all it needs is one key in order
to know which cluster node to use, then maybe another spec (if the command has several) can supply that, and there's no
need to use GETKEYS.
Each spec is an array of arguments, first one is the spec name, the second is an array of flags, and the third is an array
containing details about the spec (specific meaning for each spec type)
The initial flags we support are "read" and "write" indicating if the keys that this key-spec finds are used for read or for write.
clients should ignore any unfamiliar flags.
In order to easily find the positions of keys in a given array of args we introduce keys specs. There are two logical steps of
key specs:
1. `start_search`: Given an array of args, indicate where we should start searching for keys
2. `find_keys`: Given the output of start_search and an array of args, indicate all possible indices of keys.
### start_search step specs
- `index`: specify an argument index explicitly
- `index`: 0 based index (1 means the first command argument)
- `keyword`: specify a string to match in `argv`. We should start searching for keys just after the keyword appears.
- `keyword`: the string to search for
- `start_search`: an index from which to start the keyword search (can be negative, which means to search from the end)
Examples:
- `SET` has start_search of type `index` with value `1`
- `XREAD` has start_search of type `keyword` with value `[“STREAMS”,1]`
- `MIGRATE` has start_search of type `keyword` with value `[“KEYS”,-2]`
### find_keys step specs
- `range`: specify `[count, step, limit]`.
- `lastkey`: index of the last key. relative to the index returned from begin_search. -1 indicating till the last argument, -2 one before the last
- `step`: how many args should we skip after finding a key, in order to find the next one
- `limit`: if count is -1, we use limit to stop the search by a factor. 0 and 1 mean no limit. 2 means ½ of the remaining args, 3 means ⅓, and so on.
- “keynum”: specify `[keynum_index, first_key_index, step]`.
- `keynum_index`: is relative to the return of the `start_search` spec.
- `first_key_index`: is relative to `keynum_index`.
- `step`: how many args should we skip after finding a key, in order to find the next one
Examples:
- `SET` has `range` of `[0,1,0]`
- `MSET` has `range` of `[-1,2,0]`
- `XREAD` has `range` of `[-1,1,2]`
- `ZUNION` has `start_search` of type `index` with value `1` and `find_keys` of type `keynum` with value `[0,1,1]`
- `AI.DAGRUN` has `start_search` of type `keyword` with value `[“LOAD“,1]` and `find_keys` of type `keynum` with value
`[0,1,1]` (see https://oss.redislabs.com/redisai/master/commands/#aidagrun)
Note: this solution is not perfect as the module writers can come up with anything, but at least we will be able to find the key
args of the vast majority of commands.
If one of the above specs can’t describe the key positions, the module writer can always fall back to the `getkeys-api` option.
Some keys cannot be found easily (`KEYS` in `MIGRATE`: Imagine the argument for `AUTH` is the string “KEYS” - we will
start searching in the wrong index).
The guarantee is that the specs may be incomplete (`incomplete` will be specified in the spec to denote that) but we never
report false information (assuming the command syntax is correct).
For `MIGRATE` we start searching from the end - `startfrom=-1` - and if one of the keys is actually called "keys" we will
report only a subset of all keys - hence the `incomplete` flag.
Some `incomplete` specs can be completely empty (i.e. UNKNOWN begin_search) which should tell the client that
COMMAND GETKEYS (or any other way to get the keys) must be used (Example: For `SORT` there is no way to describe
the STORE keyword spec, as the word "store" can appear anywhere in the command).
We will expose these key specs in the `COMMAND` command so that clients can learn, on startup, where the keys are for
all commands instead of holding hardcoded tables or use `COMMAND GETKEYS` in runtime.
Comments:
1. Redis doesn't internally use the new specs, they are only used for COMMAND output.
2. In order to support the current COMMAND INFO format (reply array indices 4, 5, 6) we created a synthetic range, called
legacy_range, that, if possible, is built according to the new specs.
3. Redis currently uses only getkeys_proc or the legacy_range to get the keys indices (in COMMAND GETKEYS for
example).
"incomplete" specs:
the command we have issues with are MIGRATE, STRALGO, and SORT
for MIGRATE, because the token KEYS, if exists, must be the last token, we can search in reverse. it one of the keys is
actually the string "keys" will return just a subset of the keys (hence, it's "incomplete")
for SORT and STRALGO we can use this heuristic (the keys can be anywhere in the command) and therefore we added a
key spec that is both "incomplete" and of "unknown type"
if a client encounters an "incomplete" spec it means that it must find a different way (either COMMAND GETKEYS or have
its own parser) to retrieve the keys.
please note that all commands, apart from the three mentioned above, have "complete" key specs
